S U M M A R Y OF R E S U L T S S O F A R : Updated on Sep 6th, 2010
I was just wondering that the size of this thread has gone quite enormous and it may be difficult for the members to go through all the pages and see the results of all handguns, when they want to draw a comparison. I have therefore summarized the performance of all handguns tested so far in this post. I have also categorized them as per their size / use. The purpose of doing this is that though all handguns are being tested using the same procedure, their accuracy results do not carry equal values in my view. For example, a score of 65% by a sub-compact gun may be far better than a score of 70% by a large frame gun. Mathematical values are good as they describe the results in tangible form but in the end, members should carry out their own analysis keeping in mind their own peculiar requirements for a handgun. Hope it helps :)
LARGE FRAME HANDGUNS
1.
Taurus PT99
- Overall Score - 92.11%
- Overall Rating -
EXTREMELY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109121#p109121
2.
CZ999 Scorpion
- Overall Score - 87.11%
- Overall Rating -
VERY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109106#p109106
3.
Beretta 92FS Centurion
- Overall Score - 86.22%
- Overall Rating -
VERY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...123929#p123929
4.
Baikal MP446 Viking (#2)
- Overall Score - 86.00%
- Overall Rating -
VERY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...132818#p132818
5.
Taurus PT92
- Overall Score - 85.66%
- Overall Rating -
VERY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...139942#p139942
6.
Taurus 608 SS8 .357 Revolver
- Overall Score - 85.66%
- Overall Rating -
VERY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...123876#p123876
7.
Canik55 Piranha
- Overall Score - 85%
- Overall Rating -
VERY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...136398#p136398
8.
Norinco NP22 (#2)
- Overall Score - 84.33 %
- Overall Rating -
ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...129326#p129326
9.
Glock 17
- Overall Score - 84%
- Overall Rating -
ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...123909#p123909
10.
CF98 (#2)
- Overall Score - 82.66%
- Overall Rating -
ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...127044#p127044
11.
Baikal MP446 Viking #3
- Overall Score - 82%
- Overall Rating -
ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...136390#p136390
12.
Stoeger Cougar (#1)
- Overall Score - 81.11%
- Overall Rating -
ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...127049#p127049
13.
Zigana F (#2)
- Overall Score - 80%
- Overall Rating -
ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...160585#p160585
14.
Zigana F (#1)
- Overall Score - 78.33%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...148088#p148088
15.
Taurus PT 909
- Overall Score - 78%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...136380#p136380
16.
Baikal MP446 Viking (#1)
- Overall Score - 77.11%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...110902#p110902
17.
CF98 (#1)
- Overall Score - 76.88%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109105#p109105
18.
Stoeger Cougar (#2)
- Overall Score - 76.44%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...127057#p127057
19.
Taurus 24/7 OSS
- Overall Score - 76.22%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...123889#p123889
20.
TT 33, Winamax
- Overall Score - 75.33%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
Hot Link:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...127051#p127051
21.
Taurus 24/7 Pro
- Overall Score - 71.33%
- Overall Rating -
MODERATELY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...122588#p122588
22.
Taurus 809E
- Overall Score - 69.33%
- Overall Rating -
AVERAGE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...123343#p123343
23.
Beretta 92FS Local Clone
- Overall Score - 64%
- Overall Rating -
AVERAGE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...112080#p112080
24.
Beretta 92FS Inox (This was a very heavily used Inox in 60% condition)
- Overall Score - 63.44%
- Overall Rating -
AVERAGE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109107#p109107
25.
Norinco NP22 (#1)
- Overall Score - 58 %
- Overall Rating -
JUST ACCEPTABLE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109126#p109126
26.
Kanuni S
- Overall Score - 58%
- Overall Rating -
JUST ACCEPTABLE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109545#p109545
27.
Walther P38
- Overall Score - 54.44%
- Overall Rating -
JUST ACCEPTABLE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109516#p109516
28.
TT-36, Chinese
- Overall Score - 39.66%
- Overall Rating -
JUNK
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109522#p109522
29.
Beretta 92FS Local Clone
- Overall Score - 34%
- Overall Rating -
JUNK
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...109128#p109128
30.
Akdal Ghost TR2
- Overall Score - 24.33
- Overall Rating -
JUNK
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...112075#p112075
COMPACT HANDGUNS
1.
Glock 19
- Overall Score - 77.66%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...114230#p114230
2.
Steyer M9 A-1(Test conduct in bad light conditions in a standing position, off hand)
- Overall Score - 75.66%
Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...118732#p118732
3.
CZ75 Compact
- Overall Score - 75.33%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...114227#p114227
SUB - COMPACT HANDGUNS
1. Makarov #2
- Overall Score - 86.66%
- Overall Rating -
VERY ACCURATE
-
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtopic.
20#p133320
2. Walther PP
- Overall Score - 76.33%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
-
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtopic.
82#p136382
3. Makarov #1
- Overall Score - 75%
- Overall Rating -
FAIRLY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtopic.
84#p122584
4. Taurus PT145 (#3)
- Overall Score - 62.00%
- Overall Rating -
AVERAGE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...139937#p139937
5. Taurus PT145 (#2)
- Overall Score - 62.00%
- Overall Rating -
AVERAGE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtopic.
33#p127033
6. Taurus PT145 (#1)
- Overall Score - 48.00%
- Overall Rating -
JUST ACCEPTABLE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtopic.
68#p123868
COMPETITION / MATCH HANDGUNS
1.
Ruger MK III Competition
- Overall Score - 91.33%
- Overall Rating -
EXTREMELY ACCURATE
- Hotlink:
http://www.pakguns.com/forum/viewtop...114228#p114228
================================================== ====================
================================================== ====================
D I S C L A I M E R
While compiling this summary, my purpose was to make it easy for all members to compare the results of different handguns. However, seeing its final form now, I realise that it has somewhat become a result card kind of thing which speaks good of certain handgun guns and also bad of certain handguns. Please keep in mind following aspects while going through this summary...................
1. This by no means is a final result of some kind of ACCURACY COMPETITION held between these guns.
Neither these tests are the perfect / most scientific tests for judging the accuracy nor this should be taken as the final performance of a particular brand of handgun.
2. I realise that the results of those handguns which I have been firing more over the years or I own are better than few other guns. This is natural. So please don't get carried away too much with the mathematics. If Handgun A is scoring 77.11 and handgun B is scoring 74.34 than it does not necessarily mean that handgun A is better. Perhaps both are of same category . If PT99 and CZ999 are on top of the list than it does not mean that these are two most accurate pistols around and are better than say Glock 17 or few other because these have scored better percentage. However, it does mean that both of them are accurate handguns and can be trusted for accuracy :)
3. Few handguns have performed really bad. This again does not mean that all specimens of this brand would perform the same way. May be the one I tested was a lemon or its sights were way out.
But one thing is for sure; there is some serious problem somewhere. So please keep that handgun on your watch list and check it thoroughly before making a decision to buy it.
4.
Please do also understand my limitations as a human being. I will never be able to give a standard performance every time because it is humanly not possible; only machines can do it. Accordingly, the results may slightly vary for different handguns but not too much.
5.
This, by no means is a marketing campaign for a few handguns and a dumping campaign for the others. You may consult this as a reference but finally make your own decision while you are buying a handgun, keeping in mind your requirements and pocket.
6. Therefore,
these tests are not a most scientifically conducted final verdict on a particular handgun, however, they do provide a tangible basis for judging one of the most important characteristic of any handgun; its accuracy.
Thanks and regards :)